Pa. mine fire making news again

 

Decades later, still-steaming Centralia is home to just 10 people

CENTRALIA, Pa. -- Nearly a half-century after it began, the voracious mine fire that doomed this coal town in the mountains of northeastern Pennsylvania continues to burn hundreds of feet underground, uncontrolled and uncontrollable.

The fire began in 1962 at the town dump and ignited an exposed coal vein, eventually forcing an exodus that emptied Centralia of more than 1,000 people, nearly its entire population. Almost every house was demolished; the U.S. Postal Service canceled the town's ZIP code.

Centralia still beckons curiosity seekers. What they find is a ghost town like no other, a place with an intact street grid but almost nothing on it, where clouds of sulfurous steam waft from a rocky moonscape and the ground is warm to the touch.

About 10 holdouts still live here, ignoring government admonitions to leave. In a way, they are carrying on a tradition of proud defiance that is highlighted in a new book by the granddaughter and great-granddaughter of Centralia coal miners.

In "The Day the Earth Caved In," first-time author Joan Quigley vividly explores why so many of Centralia's residents fought to stay in a town that was struggling economically even before the fire started, a place with "no stoplight or movie theater, no restaurant or grocery store."

Most Centralians ignored the fire for years and some denied its very existence, choosing to disregard the threat posed by dangerous gases and cave-ins.

Why?

For some, it was a simple matter of economics. Centralians worked low-paying jobs but for the most part owned their homes; they couldn't afford to move and take on a mortgage.

For others, it was a matter of pride. They had lived in Centralia all their lives, just as their grandfathers and great-grandfathers before them, and couldn't imagine abandoning it.

Centralians had "scraped for work after the mines closed," Quigley writes, and "swelled with pride in their homes, their children, and their community."

Quigley, 42, grew up in Cleveland but was regaled with tales of her Centralia ancestors. Her first visit to the tiny town 90 miles northwest of Philadelphia was at age 15, when she attended her grandmother's funeral. She began researching the book in 1999, interviewing nearly 200 current and former Centralians, government officials, journalists and others.

"It has been 25 years since people starting leaving and I think that has given many former residents time to get perspective, to start lives in other communities and move on," Quigley said in a recent phone interview.

Her book reveals indifference and incompetence at all levels of government, from the borough council on up through the U.S. Department of the Interior.

The fire could have been put out for thousands of dollars when it first started, Quigley writes, but bureaucratic inertia and bungling conspired to delay an effective response until it was too late.

For Centralia, Quigley writes, the beginning of the end came on Valentine's Day, 1981, when 12-year-old Todd Domboski was swallowed by a subsidence in his grandmother's backyard, coating him with hot, sticky muck but otherwise leaving him unhurt.

The incident attracted national media attention to the mine fire and led to the formation of a group of Centralia activists -- including an ex-hippie, a motorcycle shop owner and a young, pregnant housewife, all of whom feature prominently in Quigley's story -- who pressed the government to act.

But a sizable portion of Centralia's population resented the activists. They were led by Helen Womer, a bank teller who wanted to keep Centralia intact at all costs and who rejected both a proposed government buyout and a proposed trench that would have obliterated her home.

There has been a surge in interest in Centralia recently.

Along with Quigley's book, a new feature-length documentary, "The Town That Was," follows the exploits of 30-something John Lokitis, Centralia's youngest resident, as he tries to keep the town alive. It has been screened at various film festivals and will compete at the Los Angeles Film Festival later this month.

Evansville Courier & Press - Monday, June 11, 2007

ANTON, Ky. — Julie Robichaud has an herb garden in the back of her Hopkins County home.

Yarrow. Colts foot. Soapwort. Rosemary. Catmint.

Take the tour and she'll have you chew on cilantro and sample some stevia that she says is 300 times sweeter than sugar.

The 67-year-old woman will tell you that pineapple sage makes hummingbirds go crazy, that rosemary is sometimes used in landscaping and that it's not a good idea to mess around with foxglove because the stuff can kill you.

So what was the lady's background before she changed her focus to lemon grass, black cohosh and gooseberry bushes?

Mining coal.

"I worked at the face, and I drove a shuttle car. When I became boss, I was one of Peabody's first women in that capacity.

"I never was afraid of going down the shaft. The worst thing I ever saw was a guy who got in an accident and his eyeball popped out."

Julie Robichaud laughs.

"There wasn't any place for a woman to go to the bathroom where it was, you know, private. I wouldn't drink any water and just try to hold it the whole shift. If that didn't work, I'd turn my light out and back away from where all the men was and try to find a good place."

Her husband Richard, 72, is a retired building inspector. He doesn't share his wife's knowledge of horseradish, basil and lavender.

"All I know in that backyard is where the tomato plants are."

Julie Robichaud points to a patch of Indian cup that she picked up in Texas while visiting her children.

... ...

On Wednesday, U.S. District Court Judge Charles Chamber rendered a decision regarding the legality of relying on the “waste treatment exclusion” for the construction of in-stream sediment ponds.  The waste treatment exclusion refers to a long-standing regulatory interpretation by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the federal Environmental Protection Agency where both agencies have treated sediment ponds and any area of stream between the toe of a valley fill and the inlet of a sediment pond as part of a water compliance or waste treatment system.  The plaintiffs in the case have argued that the agencies application of this exclusion was in error, and that any stream segment between the toe of the fill and the inlet to the sediment pond remained “waters of the United States”  for purposes of the Clean Water Act and that any discharge from the toe of a fill should be subject to Section 402 NPDES effluent limitations even before it enters the sediment pond.  Judge Chambers sided with the plaintiffs in the case, disregarding 30 years of regulatory application by state and federal agencies, the most recent enunciation of which was published jointly by the Corps and EPA in March of 2006.

The challenge to the water compliance exclusion was part of a larger case challenging the Corps’ issuance of four Section 404 Individual Permits to subsidiaries of Massey Energy Company.  Judge Chambers issued an adverse ruling on the four permits in March 2007.  Motions to add several other Individual permits to the litigation are still under consideration by the Court.  The Corps, the Massey subsidiaries and the Coal Association have already appealed the March 2007 decision to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, and we anticipate similar filings on this most recent decision.  The Association is discussing the ramifications of the decision with counsel and the agencies involved, and we hope to have better guidance next week.  For a copy of the decision, please contact jbostic@wvcoal.com

The deadline for filing comments on the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection’s draft Section 401 certification of the three new Section 404 General Permits for coal mining (NWPs 21, 49 and 50) is June 25, 2007.  For a copy of the state’s proposed conditions, contact jbostic@wvcoal.com